Some of you might have noticed that, around the time of the November election, some of my posts here and elsewhere became a bit more political. Honestly, I’ve always been a political person. My two favorite conversation topics are religion and politics, which – you can imagine – makes me a much beloved dinner guest in many homes. :p
But it’s a difficult mix. The one thing I criticize most harshly about American Evangelicalism is just how political it has become. I’m a fervent believer in the separation of Church and State, and I do not think salvation, spirituality or purity can or should be legislated. So I thought I’d take a moment to explain why I’ve grown a bit more political and the ways in which my faith informs my politics.
Christian but Still a Citizen
While the majority of the U.S. population claims to be Christian, I do not believe America is a Christian nation – and I think it is extremely problematic to classify it in such a way (for reasons too numerous to list here). For starters, our nation and its wealth was built on genocide and slavery.
However, I still care about my country. I like our Constitution and Bill of Rights and believe they should be preserved and defended. I also believe that governments exist to serve their people. A government that exploits its people is an abomination.
One reason I’ve become more political recently is that I believe our Constitution and the institutions that uphold it are under threat. Yes, my allegiance is to Jesus Christ first, and in Him I have peace when everything else is dissolving into chaos. But that doesn’t mean that I have to – or should – let chaos pass without comment.
One of the things I treasure most about the U.S. is our enshrined freedom of religion. That freedom allowed Protestant Christianity to flourish here when it was under attack elsewhere. Other religious minorities have flocked here to escape persecution as well. Limiting “freedom of religion” to just one religion sets a dangerous precedent. Christianity may be the main U.S. religion today, but what if an atheism becomes the majority? Or Mormonism? Or Scientology? Freedom for all religions keeps Christianity free as well.
Moral Law vs Spiritual Law
So I have these two things at work: my religious faith and my political philosophy. I try to keep the two separate, but there are points where they converge. Take, for example, the issue of welfare (which I’ve written about before). My faith says that Christians are commanded to provide for the poor and needy. Some have argued that should only occur on an individual basis – but I say if we’re going to label ourselves a “Christian nation,” then things like welfare and fair wages should be primary features of our economy.
At the same time, my political philosophy says that governments exist to serve their people and ensure their wellbeing. Therefore, even if we’re not claiming to be a Christian nation, there should still be some sort of federal provision for disadvantaged members of society – whether that’s a guaranteed minimum income, affordable education, food stamps, or some other program.
But what about legislating? Here’s where it gets a bit tricky. As I said, I don’t think purity can be legislated. But I do believe in moral laws whose main purpose is to protect and serve people, and many of these are deeply informed by my faith.
For example, I despise financial fraud or usury of any kind. I graduated from college in 2007, just as the economy was beginning to melt down from the housing bubble. I saw firsthand how financial fraud can completely devastate hardworking people. In my opinion, it is one of the world’s worst evils – and the Bible has a lot to say about charging obscene interest rates, withholding wages, stealing, and defrauding the poor. YA DON’T DO IT. It hurts humanity and makes God awfully mad.
Issues like gay marriage. Here is where I distinguish between a moral law and a spiritual law. There are a handful of verses in the Bible that appear to address homosexuality, and it is clear to me that consensual gay sex – if indeed a sin – is a sin that one only commits against himself and God. Only the participants’ spiritual state is affected; broader society is untouched. And I think activities that only impact an individual’s spiritual state – such as salvation, church attendance, relationships, etc. – should not be regulated by the government. That’s an infringement on freedom of religion.
It is the Holy Spirit and the Church’s job to address sin. It is the government’s job to address public health and ethics.
Abortion is even trickier. I’m personally opposed to abortion. I’ve never had one and, God help me, I never will. But…I have seen people encounter circumstances where termination of a pregnancy was a wise and merciful thing to do. There are valid circumstances that require women to consider it. So while I am morally opposed to the practice in most cases, I acknowledge that there are sound reasons for its existence. And for those reasons, I think it should remain legal and accessible to all women. (You may disagree.)
My Real Beef
However, there’s a bigger reason I’ve found myself more politically outspoken these days. It has to do with Christian leaders’ endorsement of Donald Trump. Normally, this would not be a huge issue for me. I grew up in a conservative church; pastors rallying around Republican candidates is nothing new for me.
What is new is the lengths to which these leaders have gone to overlook, dismiss and explain away a lifetime of Trump’s moral and ethical failings. I am both befuddled and appalled that Christian leaders sanctified – and continue to sanctify – one of the most degenerate human beings to have graced our planet in recent memory.
I do not use the word “degenerate” lightly or often.
In this case, I feel I have to speak up. My silence would be complicity in these leaders’ attempts to pass Trump off as “God’s anointed.” And I will do no such thing. History has shown that anyone who aligns himself with Trump will pay a heavy price in reputation, credibility or position. I truly believe that by embracing Trump, evangelical leaders are endangering the spiritual wellbeing of the Church.
The other day on Twitter, I wrote the following:
My entire youth, Christian leaders told me to avoid people like Trump…to be bold & courageous…to take a stand against evil. Tim LaHaye published an entire series of books on the end times, on what to expect when the Antichrist shows up. How he will speak and act. And here is Trump doing & saying exactly those things, embodying everything I was taught to stand against. And those Christian leaders are now demanding my silence. That I stand down. That I get on board and support this man.
I open the scriptures & read about people who mock, who slander, who defraud, who lie, who engage in smooth talk…I point this out…and I’m told I’m wrong. That I’m being hysterical and butthurt. God’s going to use Trump for some amazing purpose, I’ll see.
And people keep showing me these videos…here’s Trump sitting in church. Here he is being prayed over. Rev. So-and-so blessed him. And I shouldn’t speak against this because it’s rude, because people support him & my speaking out offends them.
And the thing is, I’m not out there insulting Trump voters. I’m not calling them nasty names. I’m just pointing out the deplorable things he says & does. But even this is too much, apparently. I’m not “giving him a chance” to show the good he can do.
People talk about how painful it is to abandon one’s faith. But what happens when your faith abandons you?
What happens when your leaders pivot & sanctify everything they’ve ever preached against? And label you the traitor?
I don’t yet know the answer. But I certainly won’t let their betrayal pass without comment. My faith won’t allow it.
Back in the 60’s they said “tell it like it is” and that is just what you are doing.
Reblogged this on Transform Society and commented:
Pretty interesting & insightful article!
The only problem that I personally have with denying homosexual people their rights is that it then leads to them having to hide their true nature. My Ex husband lied for 30 years about his preference–causing my physical destruction ( a drug reaction to the medication I took for the STD he gave me) my family’s breakup, and much heartache–it was hardly between just him and God. I have recently been waking up with nightmares that I have to take him back to hide his nature from Pence’s police, because as much as it was a nightmare–he is still my children’s father!
I left my Pentecostal upbringing very long ago–and in fact am considered a ecstatic mystic because of my direct connectedness to God–including healing miracles and prophecy and other stuff.
I listen and obey–that’s my part.
Love is what we are here for–that’s all I know.
I was reading a letter to the editor on an article on Townhall (I read both Blue and Red sites–to try and stay balanced) and I read in disbelief when a commenter said he did not need the Jewish author of the article to give him spiritual advice, he was a Christian (!!) and the author should keep his mouth shut. I burst out laughing–Jesus of Nazarteth is, was, will be a Jew–forever!! It brought me back to my childhood when they were telling us we should be more like Jesus and I raised my hand (always the black sheep) and asked (I was about 9) if that didn’t mean we should be Jewish, because Jesus was a Jew…I got in big trouble!!
So being given my name by God when I was at the Tomb of the Patriarchs in Hebron was not really a surprise–I found out that I too, am a Jew like Jesus. I believe it was Peter who thought all Christians needed to be Jews first–it would certainly make the understandings that Jesus came to a lot easier!! He thoughts are very common in Judism…just saying…
This is very well written.
My church has taken an approach to kind of stay out of it because the pastoral team knows that like the US as a whole, our congregation has people on both sides of the aisle.
So, they just talked about praying that God would help you make the right choice.
Some felt that they didn’t go far enough. My small group has tried to be a safe space where we could have political conversations and have it be a place where we try and explain our beliefs without judging people with a different point of view.
I think it has gone quite well. Although, I would think that because I am unafraid to speak about what I believe.
I strongly believe in keeping all religions free. If we stand by and allow another religion to be attacked, that will set the table for the day when our religion is attacked. And if we were silent when they came for someone else, others will be silent when they come for us.
Nicely written. It is interesting to see how we come to some of the same conclusions, but I have a different way of getting there than you do. It just reminds me that communication is so hard!
Your post plainly lays out what you think, and how you got there. I think when we speak to each other, we don’t typically have the ability to be so clear. Emotions get a hold of us as we try to make our point, or the other person is just trying to form their response and not really listening. It is a good reminder to me, as I try and be a sensible voice in a sea of clanging gongs.
Thank you Cheryl, my sentiments exactly. God bless.
News and current events are two of my favorite things. CNN is one of my favorite stations. I almost dread turning it on anymore because Trump is always there. Stephen King wrote a book about a demon who appears to children as a clown. The title was “IT.” James Arness was the leading man in a famous 1950s science fiction movie about giant ants. The title was “THEM!!!” In November 2016, the American people wrote a story about a male creature with orange hair who behaved horribly on the American stage, became famous for “grabbing things, and was elected President of the United States” The title of this story was “HE!!!” That is what I am calling him from now on—but I really would rather not call HE!!!—or even think about HE!!!—because doing so makes me feel clinically depressed—honestly—truly—clinically—depressed. This past three weeks have honestly been three of the worst weeks in my life as a direct result of “HE!!!.”
I hear you, friend. It’s been tough for me as well.
Pingback: Blog Roll Call | Carolina On Our Minds